| |
Facts summarized on the Human Papilloma
Virus (HPV) from Report of an External Consultants Meeting.
Department of Health and Human Services, Atlanta: Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention (CDC), December 1999.
- Approximately 30 types cause infection of genital mucosal sites,
and these genital types are generally characterized as high-risk
types (e.g., HPV 16, 18, 31, 33, 35, 39, 45, 51, 52), which are
associated with low- and high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions
(LSIL and HSIL) and invasive cancer, and low-risk
types (e.g., HPV 6, 11, 42, 43, 44), which are primarily associated
with genital warts, LSIL, and re-current respiratory papillomatosis
(RRP).
- A recent assessment of the magnitude of various STD in the U.S.
estimated an annual incidence of genital HPV infection of 5.5
million and a prevalence of current infection (detectable HPV
DNA) of 20 million. The majority of infections with all types
appear to be subclinical, detectable neither by physical exam
nor cytology, but only by the use of HPV DNA detection tests.
- Among sexually active women, over 50% have been infected with
one or more genital HPV types, approximately 15% have evidence
of current infection, 50-75% of which is with high-risk types,
and 1% have genital warts.
Although smoking, pregnancy, and use of oral contraceptives have
been variably associated with genital HPV infection, the most
consistent predictor Factor is the # of sexual partners.
- Over the last 15 years, however, the central role of HPV in
the pathogenesis of cervical cancer has been firmly established.
High-risk types of HPV are found in > 93% of cervical cancers
worldwide, with HPV 16 present in 50% and HPV 18, 31, and 45 in
another 30%.
- In the U.S., incidence rates for cervical cancer are currently
8.3/100,000, with approximately 14,000 cases and 5000 deaths annually.
- An estimated 2.5 million Pap smears with low-grade abnormalities
(e.g., atypical squamous cells of undetermined significanceASCUS,
atypical glandular cells of undetermined significanceAGUS,
and LSIL) and 200,000-300,000 Pap smears with HSIL are detected
annually in the U.S.
- Estimates for genital warts incidence rates in the U.S. may
be as high as 100 per 100,000 with a prevalence of 1.4 million.
- Estimates for RRP, a disease of both children and adults in
which papillomas of the larynx and upper respiratory tract cause
hoarseness and respiratory obstruction, are similarly imprecise,
with estimated incidence rates of 0.4 to 1.2 per 100,000 children.
the likely mode of transmission for RRP is upper respiratory tract
exposure to infected genital mucosa, at the time of delivery in
juvenile-onset disease and presumably through oral-genital sexual
contact for adults.
- Median duration of HPV incident genital infection is reported
to be 8 months, with rates of persistence of only 30% after 1
year and 9% after 2 years.
- An increasing body of data suggests that the majority of type-specific
genital HPV infections are only transiently detectable by DNA
detection techniques. Most studies have noted an inverse relationship
of age with infection as measured by detection of HPV DNA. Peak
rates are found in women < 25 years old, which is speculated
to result from clearance of infection over time in most women
as an effective immunologic response is induced.
- Women with persistent infection, especially those with high-risk
types, are at greater risk for developing CIN.
- HPV testing for triage of low-grade Pap smear abnormalities
(e.g., ASCUS, AGUS, and LSIL) : Although the majority of women
with these cytologic findings have normal histology or lesions
which are likely to regress (CIN 1), a minority (5-20%) will have
CIN 2/3. The largest evaluation to date of HPV testing for triage,
demonstrate high sensitivity (approximately 90%) and acceptable
specificity (40-65%) for detection of CIN2/3 for women with ASCUS;
similar results have been found in women with AGUS. Test specificity
and positive predictive value for detecting CIN2/3 are lower in
settings where the prevalence of HPV infection is higher, such
as younger women or those with LSIL.
- The use of HPV testing to manage women with confirmed CIN, interest
stems from natural history studies which indicate that persistent
high-risk HPV infection predicts subsequent development of CIN
2/3, and from studies of women with treated CIN which indicate
that persistent HPV is associated with recurrent CIN.
- Because the large majority of CIN 1 lesions regress without
treatment, their routine treatment is not recommended, although
close follow-up is required when treatment is deferred. Determination
of whether high-risk HPV types are present, and if so, whether
they persist, may help select a group in whom closer follow-up
and/or treatment may be most useful. Likewise, following ablative
treatment of CIN, approximately 10-15% of women will experience
a recurrence. Presence of high-risk types of HPV DNA is associated
with recurrences, and follow-up HPV testing could enhance identification
of those most likely to recur, allowing more intensive follow-up.
- Modeling studies suggest that CIN has a higher probability of
regression in younger than older women, which is likely a result
of higher rates of recently acquired genital HPV infection in
young women, whose manifestations are usually transient, in contrast
to the greater likelihood of persistent infection in older women.
- Because the large majority of cervical lesions in adolescents
are self-limited, in those with low-grade cytologic abnormalities
(e.g., ASCUS, LSIL) consideration should be given to conservative
follow-up by repeat Pap smear rather than triage by HPV testing
(since predictive value in adolescents is not well-characterized)
or by early colposcopy/biopsy.
- Studies which have attempted to assess male condom benefit for
women have generally found no evidence of protection against infection.
There are data suggesting a benefit of condom use for men, although
the studies are limited, and no data is available for female condoms
for either women or men.
- t has been speculated that treatment of genital warts might
be useful in reducing infectiousness. This premise is difficult
to test because of the lack of assays for infectivity, but is
supported by observations that treatment of genital warts with
the imunomodulating agent imiquimod reduces viral DNA and mRNA
in post-treatment biopsies and that therapy of CIN results in
clearance of HPV in follow-up cervical swabs in 70-80% of women.
However, clinically normal skin and mucosa in the vicinity of
HPV-associated lesions often contain HPV. This reservoir is thought
to explain the typical recurrence rates of 10-20% after treatment
for CIN, and 20-50% after treatment of genital warts and the fact
that treatment of partners does not influence recurrence rates
of genital warts.
- Thus, based on limited existing data, currently available therapies
for HPV-related lesions may reduce but probably do not eliminate
infectiousness, and whether the reduction in viral load which
occurs with treatment impacts future transmission remains unclear.
- Because duration of infectiousness is unknown and because genital
HPV is so common among persons who have been sexually active,
the value of disclosing a past diagnosis of HPV infection to future
sex partners is unclear, although candid discussions about past
STD should be attempted whenever possible.
- Anal cancer is a relatively uncommon malignancy, with a current
U.S. incidence rate of only 0.9/100,000. However, incidence rates
are reported to have increased over the past 20-30 years in several
countries, including the U.S., where rates increased by 96% for
men and 39% for women from 1973-97. This increase has been partly
ascribed to changes in sexual activity. There is a growing body
of data linking anal cancer to sexual behavior, especially anal
intercourse, and HPV infection.
- Women with previous cervical cancer are also at higher risk
for anal cancer, an association likely attributable to the presence
of HPV infection at both sites.
- These data have lead to consideration of the potential benefit
of anal cancer prevention programs through cytologic screening,
since evaluations to date suggest that anal Pap smears may be
similar in sensitivity to cervical smears.
|
|